That Still Happened?

California State Railroad Museum, “Wanted poster for man who robbed mail car on Shasta Limited,” 1912.

Written across the full width of the Sacramento Bee on Tuesday, January 3, 1911: “DARING BANDITS HOLD UP TWO S.P. TRAINS.” The accompanying article described a scene seemingly more appropriate for the century before.[1]

On railroad tracks near Ogden, Utah, “two masked bandits” boarded the westbound Overland Limited, shot and killed instantly William Davis a Black porter–according to witnesses in an unprovoked manner simply because Davis and the other porter were “coons”–“wounded two others and robbed the passengers and railroad employes in the Pullman cars of between $1,100 and $1,200.”

Once they finished dispossessing the California-bound passengers “they forced the engineer to uncouple the locomotive” and proceeded down the tracks towards Ogden. Along the way they came upon a freight train, which they also robbed. Perhaps because the freight train was blocking their passage or they were close enough to their destination, the robbers abandoned the tracks and headed down a county road.

Not done with their robbing ways, they “encountered a young man and two girls, returning from a dance, and robbed them of their jewels and money.” The criminals escaped and were thought to be hiding somewhere in Ogden. It was reported that this was the second train robbery in the last six months and the perpetrators were described similarly in both instances.

A local historian and journalist in Utah, Lynn Arave, writes that at least six men were arrested in connection with the crimes, but despite a “heavy reward” by the railroad lines, all were released for lack of evidence and no one was ever convicted.[2]

I will admit that this story left me feeling a little naive or less informed or at best newly educated about the occurrence of train robberies well into the twentieth century. Several of the “Wanted” posters I found on archive.org are not even parodies of how they were portrayed in mass media so many decades later. I mean get a load of this one…”All of his face below the eyes was covered with a blue bandana handkerchief with polka dots. Was cool and collected throughout the holdup and talked in well modulated, quiet but emphatic tones.”

California State Railroad Museum, “Wanted poster for the arrest of bandit who robbed mail train,” 1920.

[1] “Daring Bandits Hold Up Two S.P. Trains,” Sacramento Bee, January 3, 1911.

[2] Lynn Arave, “Ogden’s Great Train Robbery Mystery of 1911,” The Mystery of Utah History, May 9, 2014, https://mysteryofutahhistory.blogspot.com/2014/05/1911-ogdens-most-daring-train-robbery.html, accessed November 18, 2026.

Tom O'DonnellComment